I think I have figured it out. Thanks for all of your help!
It looks like Q4 (2n7000) was bad. I guess I'll be making another order to Stompbox parts! I got the original 2n7000 from Tayda, so I don't know if it was bad from the factory or I destroyed it with my soldering skills.
To figure it out, I removed the LEDs, but the problem was still there. Next, I removed Q4 and I was able to get clipping and a volume boost. I placed sockets for Q4. When Q4 was placed, the problem returned.
It looks like Q4 (2n7000) was bad. I guess I'll be making another order to Stompbox parts! I got the original 2n7000 from Tayda, so I don't know if it was bad from the factory or I destroyed it with my soldering skills.
To figure it out, I removed the LEDs, but the problem was still there. Next, I removed Q4 and I was able to get clipping and a volume boost. I placed sockets for Q4. When Q4 was placed, the problem returned.