Just in case anyone ends up following this, I addressed the clipping primarily by using a different optocoupler. The cleanest ones I have seem to reduce overall volume a fair bit. Unity is basically max on the A100k pot, but it's ok imo because I'm never really looking for a compressor to boost my signal. Though if anyone has tips on how to increase the make up volume available I'm all ears.
I also stumbled across this write up which I found very useful to make the circuit a little friendlier to different opamps, among other things.
https://atomiumamps.tumblr.com/post/158891400886/hollis-flatline-compressor-modsupdates-ive-built
Lowest noise I have is a NE5532 which is dead silent even with everything exposed on a breadboard. The LM833 has lower noise than the TL072 as well, and it seems to be the squishiest of the bunch so far. I'm not sure which I prefer yet. I've also swapped the bridge diodes to 1N5817 as I have a few extra, and I want to save the germaniums for another project.
I also stumbled across this write up which I found very useful to make the circuit a little friendlier to different opamps, among other things.
https://atomiumamps.tumblr.com/post/158891400886/hollis-flatline-compressor-modsupdates-ive-built
Lowest noise I have is a NE5532 which is dead silent even with everything exposed on a breadboard. The LM833 has lower noise than the TL072 as well, and it seems to be the squishiest of the bunch so far. I'm not sure which I prefer yet. I've also swapped the bridge diodes to 1N5817 as I have a few extra, and I want to save the germaniums for another project.