Thanks for all the suggestions and help. I put in a new diode and it seems have improved a lot. It's definitely more phaser-y, though not as much as I would expect, but I wonder if the phase 45 is just a bit less phasery than something like a phase 90?
New diode is giving 4.3 volts now. Here's the new voltages:
ic1 ic2 q1 q2
1 4.37 4.36 g 2.1-2.45v 2.1-2.45v
2 4.37 4.36 s 4.36 4.36
3 4.15 4.35 d 4.36 4.36
4 0 0
5 4.36 4.5 to 5v
6 4.36 4.5 to 5v
7 4.36 1.33 to 8.7v
8 9.38 9.36
input 9.6
d1 9.33 0
r22 9.33
New diode is giving 4.3 volts now. Here's the new voltages:
ic1 ic2 q1 q2
1 4.37 4.36 g 2.1-2.45v 2.1-2.45v
2 4.37 4.36 s 4.36 4.36
3 4.15 4.35 d 4.36 4.36
4 0 0
5 4.36 4.5 to 5v
6 4.36 4.5 to 5v
7 4.36 1.33 to 8.7v
8 9.38 9.36
input 9.6
d1 9.33 0
r22 9.33